853

news, views and issues around Greenwich, Charlton, Blackheath and Woolwich, south-east London – what you won't read in Greenwich Time

News Shopper sponsor distances itself from anti-gay rant

with 6 comments

The sponsor of the News Shopper’s letters page has distanced itself from the winner of the paper’s “star letter”, which brands homosexuality “perverted”.

Webster’s Pen Shop acknowleged the letter had “caused offence to readers”, but said the family-run firm had “no influence” on the newspaper’s choice of letter.

It said in a statement: “Webster’s Pen Shop would like to reiterate that the views expressed in this weeks News shopper does not reflect the opinions of Webster’s Pen Shop or its staff.”

When asked if the company would be reviewing its relationship with the newspaper, managing director Andrew Webster declined to comment.

The letter, published in editions delievered to homes in Greenwich and Lewisham boroughs, said the newspaper was “promoting perversity” by highlighting a local hospital being mentioned on a website as a place where gay men could meet for sex. A pen from Webster’s, which has branches across the south London suburbs and in Brighton, is to be given to the writer of the letter, which was signed Mrs S Fitzsimons of Lewisham.

The Orpington-based company was unaware of the letter’s contents until it began to receive calls about the issue on Thursday.

The News Shopper has both defended its story and attacked its critics. Web manager Simon Bull used Twitter to say on the paper’s behalf: Well, the letter in the Greenwich edition this week seems to have hit the spot for getting lots of attention and sparking a strong reaction. Just because a letter wins the pen, it’s in no way an endorsement from us of the author’s views.

In fact, it’s surprising so many people are having a go at us about it instead of responding to the author and what she thinks.”

Bull’s comments – posted two hours before he linked to any stories from the paper’s website – only served to increase criticism of the newspaper, with even a California-based Twitter account, NewsWorldToday, spreading the story. Greenwich Conservative councillor Nigel Fletcher called the letter “bigoted” and said it was “very poor judgement”.

The Eltham North representative added: “And [it’s] a big mistake to crow it’s ‘hit the spot’ in sparking disgust.”

The newspaper, based in Petts Wood and part of the Newsquest media group, directed people to its web forum to debate the letter’s contents. By 1.45pm on Friday, nobody had used the newspaper’s forum to comment on the letter.

See also Londonist, Tom Royal, and Blackheath Bugle.

The News Shopper's Simon Bull also had some words for me on my story, and my observations on the paper's web strategy...


...although I'm not sure they can be taken as complimentary.

Phew. I know the News Shopper does have a reputation for reacting really badly to criticism – take a look at the bizarre comments thread tagged onto this odd little story about a patch of blood being found outside their offices. But I’m amazed at the spite in its reaction. Twitter has got a high proportion of journalists and other media types using it. Many of those people criticising the News Shopper were journalists who live in its circulation area. Wouldn’t it be wiser to engage with its critics, instead of going on the attack?

Written by Darryl

27 August, 2010 at 2:09 pm

6 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. I see News Shopper hasn’t improved since I had to try and teach them how to count during the ‘overpaid Deptford head-teacher’ farrago earlier this summer …

    BrockleyKate

    27 August, 2010 at 2:23 pm

  2. I forgot about that. They didn’t react well to your comments there either, if I remember correctly.

    Darryl

    27 August, 2010 at 2:28 pm

  3. They rejected my attempts to explain basic accountancy to them, yes, and were pretty arrogant with it.

    What I find amazing about both cases was that News Shopper was, primarily, being criticised by other journalists, many of them very experienced (journalism.co.uk weighed in in both cases, for example). And yet whoever runs the News Shopper Twitter feed either didn’t realise or didn’t care that they were being roundly trashed by their peers. Not by the ill-informed, unpredictable consumers who all journos moan about from time to time – but other hacks. And yet they were totally unwilling to even engage.

    BrockleyKate

    27 August, 2010 at 7:02 pm

  4. […] paper last month over its reporting of the Tidemill School story. She hit the nail on the head in a comment on this site: What I find amazing about both cases was that News Shopper was, primarily, being […]

  5. […] Scores of readers criticised the newspaper on Twitter, while Greenwich councillor Nigel Fletcher branded the decision to award the letter a prize “inexcusable”. Sponsor Webster’s Pen Shop, which supplied the prize, issued a statement disassociating itself from the letter. […]


Hello! Please join the discussion below.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 515 other followers